Takeanidea

Headphoneus Supremus
UP4 a challenge - Shanling's UP4 2022
Pros: Wireless v Wired gets closer
Refreshing choice for both IEM and Full Sized Headphones
Make any headphone a decent hands free device
Cons: Lack of native support for Hi Res and DSD
Introduction

20221112_165321.jpg


I am a wealthy man, if wealth is measured by happiness. If wealth is also defined by the number of review items I have been sent over the last decade, then yes, I may also be considered abundant with riches. This particular pocket sized product has been kindly provided by aoshida audio Not only that, but it is for sale right at this very moment and can be found precisely here That means if you are interested in finding out much it costs ($114 as of launch) and you must have it, I have put you right already and thank you for your time. If you wanna know more, and you need a blow by blow, no frills, no jargon look at this here Shanling thing, with a comparison field test between this and a budget dongle, you'll be pleased to know you've arrived at the right place. I have written 100s of reviews, both of the great and the small. I treat each new arrival with the same frisson of excitement that I have always experienced in my adventures in the World of HiFi. The hunger to bring you the latest output from those who care and those who dare remains at the core of my motivation. If this disappears, so will the reviews. It would seem that, despite my having little time available to pitch to the manufacturers out there I am still supplied with a steady stream of audio to mess around with. Honestly, I do have my own stuff and would love to talk about that. This appears unlikely given how much I am constantly being sent.
About the UP4 22

20221112_165439(1).jpg


The Shanling family has reinvented their alleged "best selling" UP4 with a new Dual DAC Chip, the ES9219C. Although I compare this to a budget Dac Dongle, the Jade Audio Fiio KA1, it isn't really a dongle. Shanling have plenty of those available. The Dac Dongle carries no power itself, instead feeding from the charging port of mother, the smart or iPhone, or from the voltage of the USB port of the laptop or PC. The UP4 is a bluetooth equipped ultra portable USB Dac Amp. It is a little more versatile. It doesn't drain your smart phone battery in the same way as a dongle. Once you have seen how good the audio from the wireless aspect is, you won't have the worries of a cable attached to the bottom of your phone. Cables can snap, causing terminal damage to your device or your smartphone, or, worse still, to both. Better to have your phone in your pocket and your dac amp at arms length. The UP4 makes for a pretty nifty hands free device. It comes with a snap on carry clip. Attach that to the top of your t shirt, or if you live in the Northern Hemisphere, it'll be to the neck part of your coat at the moment. When a call comes through, it takes a simple press of the volume wheel and you are in a conversation. Using your headphones as the receiver and a knowles microphone as a transmitter, you have a pretty snazzy setup and don't need to look like a cretin by holding your phone horizontally and enabling the speaker. As you can tell, this is a pet hate of mine. Not everyone wants to be distracted by a telephone call, an interaction I have always felt is a private affair. The UP4 22 carries a good bit of onboard power, for a decent amount of time. I am led to believe there is 300 hours of standby time available, which means there seems little point in switching it off. When I say versatile, I mean it. There are 2 output connections. I will talk about both. The 3.5mm is not just your typical, boring unbalanced jack. This jack will cover all of your iem needs. There are 3 output modes for the unbalanced. I was puzzled as to why so much attention had been placed on what is normally viewed as a rather unglamorous slot. I get it now. It makes perfect sense. Mode 1 - I'm gonna call that Normal mode. That is suited to your super efficient KZ/CCA/KBear/Moondrop budget iem models. Mode 2 - let us say that is high power mode. Definitely good for your hybrids and customs. Mode 3 harnesses the twin power of the dual dac chip - Shanling call it boost mode. Almost like a flux capacitor, Planar IEMs, the latest must haves for the fashion conscious, eat this power up. They love it. It is what they crave. What this boils down to is a respectable 100mW at 32 Ohms, with every sail up and the wind blowing briskly. It doesn't stop there. The UP4 has a balanced cable. The balanced connection has just 2 modes to satisfy the needs of the user. Why less, you may ask? I ponder such things at great length, so you don't have to. Because the UP4 is the size of a lighter there is only so much power available. There are only so many gears you can go up. That being said, normal mode in balanced is naturally catering for IEMs with the posh 2.5mm cable. I know you have some of these, and I know you'll be itching to find out what they sound like in the UP4. In time, dear reader, in time. The high mode for 2.5mm delivers a solid 165 mW at 32 Ohms. This is a 65% difference on the 3.5mm jack, and although I am a Rocket Scientist(maybe not in this life) it doesn't take any skills in quantum mechanics to realise that this is where your full sized headphones are going to be comfortable. I apologise if you don't have the relevant cable because you really need to get one if you intend to use the likes of the HiFiMan Sundara with the Shanling. The unbalanced jack does not unleash the type of power that makes a full sized Planar start to work properly. A balanced jack needs a balanced cable. I have a balanced cable with a 4.4mm termination. Therefore I needed a 4.4mm to 2.5mm adapter which set me back £9 on Amazon. A full cable will cost much more unfortunately. I am forever chasing more and more cable configurations and if, like me, you find this frustrating, I sympathise. On this occasion I forgive Shanling. The investment is well worth the money. Not only do you get more power, but the sound quality goes from so so to HiFi for full sized phones.


UP4 22 in use

20221112_165502.jpg
received_862647938245463.jpeg
received_862772318250444.jpeg


Bluetooth mode
The advantages of Wireless are will continue to reap ourselves, the punters, improvements in sound quality as our audio engineers strive to wean us away from the direct connections we have been enjoying for the past 100 years. The Bluetooth 5 chip is a bang up to date Qualcomm CSR8675. It can play all your files in LDAC mode without so much as a s.s.s.s.sssstutter. Being that LDAC is lossless, the theory goes that there shouldn't be too much difference between the format you start with (WAV,FLAC) and the LDAC conversion. In fact, I tried the UP4 as an OTG device using the USBC and USB Audio Player Pro and tested it against using Shanling's own Eddict Player and Bluetooth. The results went in favour of the wireless mode, particularly noticeable being the reduced output using the OTG method. Consider myself won over by the UP4's bluetooth. For once, convenience and practicality are combined with good sound quality, so much so, that I have not been tempted to cabilise my smartphone since the test.
Dac Mode

20221112_165640.jpg
20221112_165901.jpg


Connecting up to a laptop or PC is as simple as plugging the supplied charging cable into an available USB port. The UP4 is instantly recognised. I used it on my aged but venerable 2014 Macbook Pro Retina. There were 2 findings I must convey to you. Discovery no.1 - my posh, expensive audivarna software only recognised 44.1 and 48 as available formats for the UP4. Native DSD playback, even 24 192 hi res FLAC, is not achievable from the Shanling. This bolsters my opinion that this is primarily a bluetooth dac amp. Everything plays, but is converted through the UP4's hardware. Revelation no.2 - the extra voltage being pushed from the Macbook pushes the output of the UP4 upwards. The UP4 2022 goes significantly louder through the Macbook when compared to using my smartphone. This is good news for users of less sensitive headphones than the Sundara, and offsets some of the disappointment of the lack of format compatibility. What I'm saying is that even more headphones start to become useable if you are wanting this in your study. Not a Susvara and not an HE6, nor an AKG K1000. Be reasonable! This is tiny!
Sound quality

20221112_170021.jpg
20221112_170113.jpg


As promised, I deliver no jargon, no fills and no nonsense in my description of the sound quality. I also remember requesting your patience earlier on in this article. You need wait no longer. I compared the UP4 to the KA1 from Jade Audio, Fiio's budget subsidiary. The KA1 is something I've reviewed at length before, and I liked it. It should be noticeably below the capabilities of the UP4. It is. The KA1 connects directly to your smartphone and will play MQA and DSD natively. Despite that, the UP4 sounded more alive, more full of room, with a larger, but not bloated, bass presence and enough of those tiny little details to satisfy those of you suffering from upgraditis to feel you have a temporary respite from your affliction. A HiFiMan Sundara has been my weapon of choice for the majority of my listening, and for the YouTube demo I have posted here. I tried the Moondrop Chu for the 3.5 in unbalanced normal, the Sennheiser IE800 in unbalanced high and the Dioko 7hz Timeless Crinacle Planar in boost mode. The Shlouer Tape Electrostat reassured my faith in the lush sparkle of these super duper IEMs. I managed to snag the 2.5mm version of these. I made a blind purchase of these, as I did the Crinacle's. I have been satisfied with my instincts, and I would say that the Tape's outperform the Crinacle Planar, which is no slouch in itself.
Conclusion

20221112_165718.jpg
20221112_165620.jpg


It never ceases to amaze me what can be thought up in the offices of so many Chinese Audio Companies. I mean, how many times can you reinvent the wheel? You have a smartphone jack to plug your earphones into. You can add a Dac dongle and improve things. The ultra portable bluetooth dac amp follows. Perhaps a Mojo 2, as a strap on? Then the desktop, then the separates, incorporating any number of boxes, for dedicated clocks, power supplies, monoblock amps. You name it. There is a market ready to receive it. The choice is bewildering, the quality questionable at times. To make things even more complicated, Shanling start throwing things like the UP4 22 at us and even the adage "cheap and cheerful" doesn't make sense anymore. All I know is this; each of the steps up from your smartphone jack should make an improvement in your enjoyment of the music you love, the passion for our hobby is reliant on this and this alone. I am confident in stating the UP4 achieves this aim and submit this article as subjective evidence m'lud. Now...where did I put that adapter?
Last edited:
senorx12562
senorx12562
Sorry, but no bluetooth codec is lossless, not even LDAC.
  • Like
Reactions: Carpet
Takeanidea
Takeanidea
There's absolutely no need to apologise

o0genesis0o

Headphoneus Supremus
Shanling UP4 - Volume wheel! Oh, the sound is good too.
Pros: - Excellent in-hand feeling and handling
- Great design and build quality
- Long battery
- Varying tonality (non-boost vs boost mode, two types of filters)
- Warm and smooth tonality (comparing to Apple dongle and Fiio KA3)
Cons: - Even with Andromeda and orchestral recording, the soundstage of UP4 does not extend as wide and deep as some other competitors
- Audio delay with all Bluetooth codec
- User interface and interaction can be a bit cryptic
UP4_7.JPG


Bluetooth DAC/AMP combos always feel oxymorons to me. You buy external DAC/AMP to maximize sound quality. Yet, you use a lossy connection (Bluetooth) that reduces the sound quality you seek to improve.

Still, I use Bluetooth DAC/AMP combos because they are small, do not drain the phone's battery, and sound decent with a good Bluetooth codec like LDAC. Can UP4 (2022 version) up my Bluetooth DAC/AMP game? Let's find out.

Before we geek out, I would like to address casual listeners who stumble across this review (welcome!): UP4 is a convenient and competent device that does its job well. Suppose you get this source or alternatives around the same level. In that case, you will not bottleneck the sound quality of your IEMs or headphones (unless you plan to use something intense like DCA Stealth). The rest of this article is nitty-gritty details for those of us who are nuts about sound quality.

UP4_15.JPG


Preambles:


  • The Shanling UP4 2022 used for this article is a review sample provided by Aoshida-audio (thank you!) I have no financial interest in Shanling, Aoshida-audio, nor the success of this product.
  • Shanling UP4 (2022 version) is available exclusively at Aoshida Audio (non-affiliated link). The unit costs $119.99 at the time this review is published.
  • I use the term "source" to denote a DAC + Amp combo.
  • I found that sources do not sound the same due to the difference in their output power or tuning, should the manufacturer decide to deviate from the flat frequency response.
  • Making loud noises does not mean that a pair of IEMs or earphones are driven to their full potential. When fed more power, underpowered IEMs or earphones would sound crisper and more separated (thus making the soundstage feel larger).
  • I consider the Apple dongle a benchmark (3/5 - adequate) because it is good enough and familiar to almost everyone.
  • A source is rated based on A/B tests using Andromeda (very sensitive IEM) and E5000 (very insensitive IEM). If one source sounds not as good as the other, I would bump up the volume and give it another try before concluding. This practice aims to mitigate the "louder is better" problem without getting into the issue of "DB vs perceived loudness."
  • Despite my textual descriptions, improvements from sources are minor and nuanced. If you are beginning your head-fi journey, getting different IEMs or earphones would yield more benefits. If you know your gears very well, improvements from sources can be delightful.


Specs:


UP4_1.JPG


Product info page: here. Noted that Aoshida-audio seemed to be the only place on the Internet with the updated unit description by the time I wrote this article.

  • DAC Chips: ES9219C x 2
  • Output ports: 3.5mm (single-ended), 2.5mm (balanced)
  • Single-ended output power: 71mW@32ohm per channel
  • Boost mode (dual DAC powering the single-ended output): 100mW@32ohm per channel
  • Balanced output power: 165mW@32ohm per channel
  • Battery Life: 9.5 hrs BAL, 11.5 hrs single-ended
  • Wireless: Bluetooth 5.0, supports LDAC / LHDC / aptX HD / aptX LL / aptX / AAC / SBC
  • Built-in microphone

UP4_12.JPG


In the box


UP4_2.JPG

UP4_4.JPG

UP4_3.JPG

UP4_5.JPG


Handling and Usability:


UP4_6.JPG


Shanling UP4 is a small and light DAC/AMP that fits in the palm of your hand. It has a metal frame with front and back glass panels. I think the glass panels have a layer of oleophobic coating because removing fingerprints and smudges are easy. However, UP4 is still a fingerprint magnet, so this is something to pay attention to if you like your stuff pristine.

UP4_13.JPG

UP4_14.JPG


I really like the in-hand feeling of UP4. The curves of the unit make it fit in my hand. My thumb and index finger land on the wheel and the mode button naturally without reaching.

To me, the volume wheel is the star of the show. It rotates easily with tactile steps, making volume adjustment a physical and direct activity. I enjoy volume adjustment so much that I don't even want to turn on volume normalization when shuffling my playlists. I am also glad to report that I did not experience unintended volume changes when keeping UP4 in my jacket pocket.

Speaking of control, I was a bit concerned when realizing that UP4 has only two buttons and a led light for the "user interface". UP4 takes a bit of time to get used to compared to something with a screen like Shanling UP5 or Fiio BTR5. However, I found UP4's control more convenient in the end.

Below are some key points to get you started.

Led indicator (the ones that I actually see)
  • Blinking Blue: connected to a device via Bluetooth
  • Blinking Cyan (when audio is playing): the current connection is AAC
  • Blinking Green (when audio is playing): the current connection is LDAC
  • Blue after long press Mode button: Fast roll-off digital filter
  • Green after long press Mode button: Apodization fast roll-off digital filter
  • Blue after short press or double press Mode button: low gain
  • Green after short press or double press Mode button: high gain
  • Yellow after short press or double press Mode button: dual DAC boost mode

control:
  • Use the wheel to control the volume
  • Click the wheel to start/stop audio and accept incoming phone
  • Double-click the wheel to jump to the next song
  • Triple-click the wheel to return to the previous song
  • Short-press the mode button to check the current gain setting
  • Long-press the mode button to change the digital filter
  • Double-press the mode button to change the gain setting

My favourite feature of UP4 compared to my BTR5 is the ability to quickly change the gain setting and digital filter without going through any menu. As you will see in the sound performance section, these settings have slight but noticeable differences in the sound signature of UP4.

The Bluetooth connectivity of UP4 is solid and reliable. I can leave my phone in my office and visit my colleagues in a next-door office (same floor) without breaking the connection. I don't need to ensure line-of-sight between my phone and the dongle like I do with my BTR5.

It should be noted that UP4 is more suitable for music than movies and games. I hear noticeable delays when watching drum covers on YouTube with LDAC, AAC, and USB-C cables.

Note on the audio stuttering issue:


There have been reports of frequent audio cut-outs during music playback via Bluetooth and wired connections with some UP4 units. I have also experienced this issue. It happens more often and is more noticeable in boost mode. Noted that these cut-outs sound different from Bluetooth connection dropping and happens regardless of the connection type. Shanling has published a firmware update to fix this issue. If you use an Android device, the update can be performed wirelessly using the Eddict player app. The process is fast and easy.


Sound Performance


Source chains for A/B tests
- iPhone XR -(Lightning)-> Apple dongle -(3.5mm)-> Andromeda 2020 & E5000 (Stock cable on both)
- Mi A1 -(USB-C & LDAC)-> Shanling UP4 2022 -(3.5mm, Boost Mode)-> Andromeda 2020 & E5000 (Stock cable on both)
- Mi A1 -(USB-C)-> KA3 -(3.5mm)-> Andromeda 2020 / E5000 (Stock cable on both)

Test track: Polonaise de concert, Op. 4][: Useful for testing the instrument separation (related to output power), overall tonality (tuning), and handling of high-pitched instruments (filters).

Sound Overview


UP4_9.JPG


UP4 has a slightly warm tonality with slightly smoothened note attacks, especially in the treble region. The extra driving power of UP4 helps sharpen note attacks compared to weak dongles like the Apple dongle. The overall sound signature is noticeably different, though not day-and-night, than other sources with similar DAC and AMP configurations.

Shanling UP4 2022 has a few different sound signatures depending on your power output and digital filter choice. The low-gain and high-gain modes sound the same, just with different loudness. When you activate the boost mode, the overall sound signature becomes more "weighty", and the bass hits feel more impactful (this is not bass boost, to be precise). However, the mid and high are slightly fuzzier, which might be due to an increased noise floor. My Andromeda picks up these subtle changes more clearly than my E5000.

UP4_8.JPG


The filters also make a subtle but noticeable difference to the sound, particularly in upper-midrange and treble. The blue filter (Fast roll-off) makes the violin crisp, even slightly harsh. The crispness of the blue filter is helpful for dense and fast musical passage, as it makes instruments a bit more separated from each other. The green filter (Apodization fast roll-off digital filter) makes the violin smoother. I ended up using the green filter in most listening sessions.


Handling sensitive IEM


UP4_10.JPG


The test of UP4 starts with Andromeda 2020, the most sensitive IEM in my collection that highlights all imperfections of sources. How does UP4 handle Andromeda 2020?

I would say Andromeda sounds noticeably better on UP4 compared to the Apple dongle. This improvement boils down to two elements. Firstly, the violin is slightly rounded off, making the whole sound signature less edgy. Secondly, the background details come through clearer. The orchestra sounds weightier due to additional power in the lower frequencies.

The non-boost mode (low-gain and high-gain) makes the orchestra less weighty but a bit cleaner. The boost mode gives a bit more impact to the low end. UP4 provides Andromeda with an almost pitch black background, with only slight hiss noise with boost mode on.

How does UP4 compare to Fiio KA3, my reference dongle? There are noticeable differences. I hear a larger soundstage on KA3. For instance, in the Nutcracker, KA3 separates the violin from the orchestra and pushes the orchestra further away from me. The trade-off is all instruments sound edgier on KA3.

KA3 makes symphonies and concertos more immersive on Andromeda, whilst UP4 makes the tonality warmer and smoother. Dare I say more "musical"?

Handling demanding IEM


UP4_11.JPG


Our power output test starts with the usual suspect: Final Audio E5000. Don't let the low impedance of this IEM tricks you. E5000 is notoriously power-hungry due to its low sensitivity. Yes, you might be able to get loud enough sound out of these IEMs. Still, the lack of electrical current would spray distortion over the frequency response, making E5000 muddy and mushy.

How does UP4 handle E5000?

Way better than the Apple dongle, especially in the boost mode. For instance, let's consider the musical phrase from 2:10 of the Polonaise de Concert and pay special attention to the cellos playing a tremolo section with a crescendo around 2:30.

With the Apple dongle, the violin is decently clear. Still, the whole background is muddy and lacking detail. The Cello section is reduced to a loud, low-pitched blob of noise without any articulation (think of note attacks when bows catch the strings).

In both low-gain and high-gain modes, UP4 renders both the violin and the orchestra clearer than the Apple dongle. However, the background cellos do not reach the level of detail and texture I expect. Only when I engage the boost mode do I hear the detailed and textured rendering of cellos that I want.

When I swap to KA3, I hear an improvement in clarity, detail, and texture across the orchestra. The soundstage also feels larger. When A/B tests, I also notice that UP4's soundstage has an uncanny effect. The violin is pushed toward me a bit too far that it seems to be somewhere behind my head. I did not hear this presentation on both Apple dongle and KA3.

Conclusion


Pros:
  • Excellent in-hand feeling and handling
  • Great design and build quality
  • Long battery
  • Varying tonality (non-boost vs boost mode, two types of filters)
  • Warm and smooth tonality (comparing to Apple dongle and Fiio KA3)

Cons:
  • Even with Andromeda and orchestral recording, the soundstage of UP4 does not extend as wide and deep as some other competitors
  • Audio delay with all Bluetooth codec
  • User interface and interaction can be a bit cryptic

UP4 is a competent and well-designed product. I love the volume wheel. For casual listeners, UP4 can handle most of your music listening needs and give you a bit of room for future upgrades with the 2.5mm balanced output. For seasoned listeners, UP4 offers various sound signatures that you can change on the fly.

Sound quality wise, UP4 slots neatly between the Apple dongle (3/5 - Average) and Fiio KA3 (4/5 - Good). The excellent handling and enjoyable user experience is a big plus. On the other hand, audio delay does limit UP4 usability. Taken all aspects into consideration, I rate UP4 3.5/5 (above average).

UP4_summary.jpg
Last edited:
Sulbh
Sulbh
How does it compare to BTR5 2021 in terms of sound?
o0genesis0o
o0genesis0o
@Sulbh I have BTR5 2019, which should be similar to the 2021. In rapid A/B tests, UP4 sounds warmer and "rounder" but with less separation than BTR5. If I exaggerate a lot, I would say UP4 sounds kind of warm and gooey / soupy, which can be very enjoyable and "musical". BTR5, on the other hand, is flat and straightforward with better separation but not very dynamic.

Of course, these traits are highly exaggerated. I don't stress too much about which one to use if I need a portable DAC/AMP for the day, though I do notice their sonic difference to know that I'm using a Shanling or a Fiio. Both are good devices to pair with IEMs. If you already have BTR5 2021, I recommend going to BTr7, or even better, Topping G5, rather than sticking around this level of devices.
Back
Top