Pianist
Headphoneus Supremus
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2007
- Posts
- 3,994
- Likes
- 113
Mostly imagination, unless it is a binaural recording IMO.
Mostly imagination, unless it is a binaural recording IMO.
Don't worry about sound stage unless you're listening to Classical music, I think, or something else where they're not playing the sound directly into the mic....
I really think the recording is what will make sound stage 'realistic'... quieter sounds will seem farther away, and louder ones will seem closer. Of course you have to know yourself what is actually normal to know what is far and what is close... If you've never heard and instrument live before you might not be capable of that.
The idea that headphones have anything to do with that... seems really silly. Like, unless they're really awful and over/under emphasizing certain frequencies, there's no reason for it not to sound like the recording.
Steve Deckert (of Decware) says (in an article extolling the *virtues* of headphones for audiophile listening, mind you) that headphones basically *dont* image, flat-out, that it is just impossible for them to create that three-dimensional-space without three-dimensional space in which to work. (See "The Headphone advantage": http://www.decware.com/paper48.htm
The answer is simple,
Phase, we can detect phase with reference to other waves only not on its own. The better a headphone driver responds to phase changes and the faster it does the more accurate the sound stage.
I've never been able to perceive anything beyond the phase of the recording itself with headphones. I don't know how you could hear true speaker soundstage, or anything resembling it without a room. The room is what creates the soundstage.