Many thanks to Fiio for extending the opportunity to review the new X5 3rd Gen as part of their review tour.
A brief look at packaging
Attractive boxes, sensible layout, nice accessory package.
Before sound
A note on objectivity
Objective measurements serve as a basic benchmark of audio performance that all audio manufacturers should strive towards, and one in which Fiio products have traditionally fared very well in. They offer a measure of objective transparency and provide credence to the marketing claims of a product’s performance vis-a-vis other competing devices (including smartphones).
As expected, the X5 performs admirably here, but I still look forward to loaded (ie. real world) measurements of the X5.
Headphone out specifications (3.5mm headphone out jack) | |||
Output power 1 | ≥480 mW(16Ω / THD+N<1%) | Output impedance | <1Ω (32Ω loaded) |
Output power 2 | ≥250 mW(32Ω /THD+N<1%) | Channel separation | >73 dB (1 kHz) |
Output power 3 | ≥28 mW(300Ω / THD+N<1%) | THD+N | <0.003% (1 kHz) |
Frequency response | 5 Hz~55 kHz(-3dB) | Peak output voltage | >8 Vp-p |
SNR | ≥115 dB (A-weighted) | Max. output current | 250mA (For reference) |
Balanced headphone out specifications (2.5mm TRRS headphone out jack) | |||
Output power 1 | ≥400 mW(16Ω / THD+N<1%) | Output impedance | <3Ω (32Ω loaded) |
Output power 2 | ≥240 mW(32Ω /THD+N<1%) | Channel separation | ≥98 dB (1 kHz) |
Output power 3 | ≥26 mW(300Ω / THD+N<1%) | THD+N | <0.003% (1 kHz) |
Frequency response | 5 Hz~55kHz(-3dB) | Peak output voltage | >7.5 Vp-p |
SNR | ≥111 dB (A-weighted) | Max. output current | >250 mA (For reference) |
Subjective preamble
Beyond numbers and graphs, differences in voicing may nonetheless exist between sources which are important to consider. While these differences may ultimately be small, they can result in disproportionately large differences in the subjective experience of listening to music in terms of enjoyment and immersion.
Sound quality
That said, I have found the subjective performance of the X5 to be respectable but not particularly impressive. Make no mistake, the X5 is not remotely a bad sounding player, and in fact has quite an enjoyable and pleasing sound. It just has a few caveats which I have found to take away from MY own listening enjoyment which I feel are important to note for your consideration. Broken down into various aspects:
Soundstaging comes in with a solid performance. It does not sound compressed or claustrophobic in the least, but it is not particularly spacious either.
Separation and general resolution is rather underwhelming. The X5 does not sound congested but imaging is not especially precise or defined and note edges have a soft tone.
Presentation is intimate, present and engaging, but notably soft and smooth (no accentuation of textural details, stage elements not exaggeratedly distinct)
Bass has impressive if slightly elevated body and heft, making for a chunky, visceral sound that can be very satisfying. However, it is a little muddy and does not have the last say in punchiness and control which causes it to fall a little short in offering grit and realism.
Midrange is largely a matter of personal taste. It is forward and engaging but soft in character. It is not notably textured or detailed and has a comforting and pleasant presentation.
Treble is present and detailed but smooth.
Overall, the X5 generally meets but does not exceed expectations. Presentation is smooth and pleasing, while bass is visceral and impactful but could stand to be more controlled.
Not sound
Build and design
The X5 is gorgeous, functional and constructed impeccably. It features a compact design, tasteful angles, thoughtfully laid out transport buttons which are easy to identify and press, a sleek and well constructed volume wheel, a premium finish, attractive glass back panel and secure headphone ports.
My only gripe, which amounts to so much more of a shame in light of the otherwise fantastic design, is the awkward power button placement. It is too high up to reach comfortably one-handed and results in frequent misclicks of the play/pause button flanking the the same position on the opposite side.
Software
Speed is passable. There is a slight delay with certain actions, but it doesn’t significantly hamper over experience or operation. Overall experience remains fluid other than a few hiccups and is very much usable.
Android interface is familiar and easy to use. Downloading third party apps such as Spotify and Tidal can be done through the Play Store or the FiiO Market which is less polished but still simple to use.
Pure music mode works well and is mostly smooth and intuitive to operate.
The X5 is absolutely jam packed with useful features, most notable being:
Wifi support (OTA updates and streaming):
- Streaming apps work well. No stutters or crashes
- Rather poor wifi reception. Slow OTA updates and streaming hiccups even for lossy 320 kbps Spotify tracks with a single concrete wall separation.
Filters
- Hard to access, quick settings bring up settings page rather than allowing immediate selection of filter choices.
- Minimal differences between filters. You might find a preference but honestly I struggle to tell a difference between filters beyond a vague gut feel.
Effects
- Channel balance (this should be a standard inclusion on every DAP honestly)
- Vipereffect
- About half of the features are locked behind a paywall (payment can be done through WeChat, Alipay or Paypal) but there is still a good selection of free effects like various surround simulations, gain adjustment, and upscaling
- Effects generally work well but there is a few seconds of delay before the settings take effect making finding the right setting quite laborious.
- Overall nothing astounding (at least based on the free effects) but nice to have the additional functionality and features.
- USB dac installation much easier than before. No need to allow unsigned drivers in Windows settings.
- Software is laden with features usually absent on other daps featuring USB DAC functionality such as channel balance and even basic but important functions like volume adjustment with the screen off.
- However, some issues remain such as occasional crashes when changing usb streaming settings in the fiio driver software and notable latency making it unsuitable for video streaming/gaming. It is bearable on “minimum latency” setting but latency is still noticeable.
- Seems to not work through USB hubs whereas other dac/amps like my HA-2 worked just fine.
- Instant play/pause, no idle mode where the amp turns off after certain durations of inactivity.
I could not get the USB OTG out option to work even with third party apps like the Onkyo HF player to test the X5 with external DACs.
Usability quirks
- Amp section turns off after short period of disuse and produces audible clicks when turning off/on. Delay in output when turning on (almost 2 seconds).
- Occasional clicks when switching between tracks (either selecting a different track or simply during continuous playback)
- Power button too high up and positioned opposite the play pause button leading to accidental pauses.
Battery
About 8 hours (just short of 10 hours as per Fiio’s claims), capable of lasting several days between charges depending on usage.
Should you buy it?
At the end of the day, the X5 3rd Gen presents an incredible value considering it’s outstanding feature set (including streaming support, dual micro-sd slots, quick charging, balanced output), sensible and attractive design, and incredibly competitive price point.
However, it’s few usability quirks do amount to palpable annoyances in day to day usage and while the X5 is far from a bad sounding player, it’s relatively soft, smooth voicing and modest subjective technicalities mean you should probably give it a listen to see if it pairs well with your existing setup and if it suits your tastes before purchasing one.
Overall, the X5 is still a good sounding player and presents a strong value proposition worthy of a 4/5 rating.
Imaging/soundstage blew me away. Admittedly I'm not a long term nor expert DAP user but sometimes I'll be looking around the room to see where certain sounds are coming from, a bit freaky IMO. Don't get that with my stereo and headphone set up from days past on the same music.