The product was provided to me free of charge for the review purpose in exchange for my honest opinion. The review was originally posted on my
blog, and now I would like to share it with all my readers on Head-fi.
Manufacturer website:
Cayin, for sale on
MusicTeck and Amazon.
*click on images to expand
Intro.
I used to consider saturation of DAP market as a good thing. After all, competition should benefit consumers and challenge manufacturers to introduce more innovations to stand out from the crowd. But too much “saturation” can have a negative effect. Today, DAP market resembles smartphones, and even worse. Seems that every few months there is yet another release, and the focus shifted from improving audio quality to adding more features, resulting in compromises. I'm sure many manufacturers feel frustrated too, but I think it affects even more the consumers who spend months researching and comparing, ready to pull the trigger, and then something new is announced and you are back to square one.
I was excited last year when Cayin announced their upcoming i5 DAP, and appreciated their honestly when the release was delayed to fix wifi interference problem. Having tested and reviewed
C5,
N6, and
N5 in the past, I always held Cayin in high regard and found them to have solid releases with unique design and great sound quality. As a matter of fact, ever since I received i5, about 4+ months ago, I have featured it in most of my headphones and DAP reviews as a source and for comparison. Unfortunately, while waiting for more fw updates and under a flood of other review samples (and a few things in my personal life, as many have probably noticed I slowed down with reviews), I never got to write a full i5 review and now deeply regret it. There are no excuses, though this is not going to be my usual long review, but rather a
shorter version (by my standards, since it has a limited comparison and pair-up). I felt like going back to review i5 helped me rediscover this DAP (and its standing among other mid-fi performers) and it deserves another ray of spotlight, so here we go!
Unboxing & Accessories.
Like their previous products, the packaging is not too flashy but still has a very informative presentation with a bold image of i5 on the front (focusing on that unique volume wheel) and the list of key features/devices on the back to give you a quick design overview.
Accessories include USB-C to USB data/charging cable (yes, i5 broke the mold and moved to USB-C), the micro-usb to USB-C adapter (to be able to utilize all your current micro-USB cables at home), screen protectors for the front and the back, and the user guide with a warranty card. I also received their original leather case (probably pleather) that offers a basic scratch protection, though after a while it felt a bit loose so I had to mod it with a few sticky notes under the cover on the back to "fix" that.
Later, Cayin released two optional accessories, a high-quality USB-C to Coax cable (a beautifully crafted premium cable with a braided clothe sleeve, high quality branded connectors, and a cool storage gift box). They also made available another more premium leather/pleather case; this one had a tighter fit (no more accidental nip-slip out of the case), a higher quality better touch material, and a distinct red stitching finish.
Perhaps the new case is not of the same caliber as $60 Dignis, but for $25 it’s an excellent solution to protect your i5 from scratches and to enhance the grip when you are on the go.
New case in comparison to the original one:
USB-C to Coax cable (optional):
Design.
Some Android based DAPs with a large touch screen fall into a trap of looking too smartphone-generic. Thus, different manufacturers are trying to spice up the design with beveled or non-symmetric edges or the addition of analog volume control wheel. Cayin decided to stand out from the crowd with its own unique wheel design in the upper right corner of the unit. The wheel feels very solid and has enough friction where you will need two fingers to turn it, the only time when I feel like I need to use two hands for operation. It’s not super tight, but just enough resistance so you don’t accidentally bump the volume when i5 is in your pocket.
The metal frame of the DAP is CNC machined from aerospace aluminum alloy, with a front of i5 covered by a glass with a touch screen display (3.97”), including “home” touch button at the bottom, and the back having a traditional Cayin carbon fiber plate. The unit itself has dimensions of about 126x64x14mm with approximately 196g in weight – feels very solid and comfortable in your hand with a bit of heft, but I still prefer to keep it inside the case since metal frame and carbon fiber back can get slippery.
The sides of i5 are elegantly carved with sexy lines where you can find on the left in the upper corner a power button, and on the right in the upper corner transport buttons (separate skip next/prev next to each other and next to them a play/pause). On the right at the bottom you will find micro-SD card slot (listed as “up to 200GB” but should be supporting 256GB since it was introduced later). The bottom of the DAP has USB-C port to charge, transfer data, connect coax cable, and for usb-OTG storage connection (still looking for a small usb-c otg thumb drive).
Keeping up with a cylindrical design of the volume pot in the upper right corner, the top of i5 follows the same rounded edge shape which blends in with a volume wheel. At the top, you will also find 3.5mm headphone jack. Unlike N5, i5 offers only single ended headphone port. Next to it is the Line Out output to bring out output of its AK4490 DAC to external amp connection. I gotta admit, with a symmetric positioning of identically looking 3.5mm jacks, I had to pay careful attention not to plug in headphones into LO. Perhaps, a little port dust plug is a good solution in this situation.
Other key hardware design features under the hood, in addition to AK4490 DAC carried over from N5 design, are 32GB of internal flash memory, 1GB of RAM, quad-core Cortex A7 processor, 4800 mAh battery (giving around 10hrs of playback time), and support of Bluetooth and WiFi under Android 4.4 OS (optimized by Hiby who collaborated with Cayin on this design). With a selection of quality op-amps and buffers, i5 is designed to drive about 190mW of power per channel with 32ohm load - plenty of power even for some demanding headphones (no issues driving my planar magnetic PM3, EL8C, or 470 ohm R70x). While <1ohm output impedance is a good news for multi-BA IEMs, but keep in mind that hissing will be noticeable with sensitive IEMs.
GUI.
Unlike some other Android based DAPs with audio app running on top of a regular Android OS, here Cayin along with Hiby took a different approach with "Android" being on top of the audio app. Once you boot up i5, it looks like a typical DAP with a dedicated audio interface. You are greeted with a main music page Folder view with options to access internal memory, micro-SD card, and "Cloud" with either Dropbox or LAN connections. You can also switch to Album, Artist, Genre, and Tracks view. Or click on List view to see your Favorites, Frequently Played, Recently Played, and Playlist. There is also an option to do a full search which brings up QERTY android keyboard (just like in a smartphone).
Swiping notification bar down (typical Android feature), you get a quick access to WiFi, Bluetooth, Gain setting, USB Mode (keep in mind, i5 can operate as USB DAC too), Idle shutdown, and Scheduled power off. Here, you can also adjust the brightness level of the screen and the screen time out, as well as being able to access the full Android Settings menu by clicking on the upper right corner Icon. People with Android phones will feel here just like at home, iOS users will need to spend a little bit of time getting used to it.
Swiping the main screen to the right, reveals more Setting options for Music scan (scan all or the specified folder), Equalizer (10band paragraphic EQ with 31/62/125/250/500/1k/2k/4k/8k/16k bands and a few genre-specific presets), Sleep Time, and more expanded Music Setting with gain, digital filter, DSD gain compensation, SPDIF Out, Play through folder, Start up and max volume, channel balance, breakpoint resume, gapless, album art, and lyrics display.
So, where are the Android apps?!? You will find it in a secluded section under Third-Party applications which opens a new screen with installed apps, including Google Play store. For a better management of the memory (only 1GB of available RAM after all), Advanced Task Killer is already pre-installed and built into the bottom of the screen for a fast access. I have installed a small handful of apps, such as Spotify and a few games. Everything seems to be working as expected, though I do want to note that download is on a slow side (especially when you downloading OTA fw updates). I have free Spotify and found no issues with streaming. Cayin already mentioned about a known issue with Tidal streaming which is not entirely under their control, and now waiting for a final resolution.
Unfortunately, that is a problem with Android support. Now, your users are tapping into the 3rd party apps which can slow down or crash Android OS, something which is not under control of Cayin. Thus, it becomes a double edge sword. Customers are asking for streaming, so manufacturer builds their OS on Android platform. But that also opens a can of worms with people installing various apps which are not under control of the manufacturer (Cayin). When something doesn't work, people blame the manufacturer who has nothing to do with this since they are not developers of the app.
The only thing they are in control of is the main DAP interface and the Playback screen which has been designed with a collaboration of Hiby, a company which has a lot of experience in audio apps and writing audio drivers to bypass Android SRC (sample rate conversion where OS down-samples audio files as a common denominator to all other apps accessing the audio). The main Playback screen has a very clear layout with upper top half of the screen occupied by a song artwork (if one is available) which could be switched to lyrics view (if embedded with a song) or a very elegant Stereo VU Meter. Underneath you have selection of different loop modes (single, repeat, random, etc.), shortcut to access EQ, view the list of songs in a current playback folder, and being able to add to favorites.
Below is a display of a song/artist name and playback controls with Skip Next/Prev on the sides a Play/Pause in the middle of a circle with a playback time marker. Interestingly, to scrub through the track, so you can fast forward to a specific time in the song, you must touch and glide your finger around the circle edge. It's a neat graphic feature, but also a bit awkward since as you moving the finger you partially blocking the circle where the time marker is located. I wish there would have been an alternative layout to have a straight fast forward scrub bar. Also, as a general comment, the touch interface is not super responsive, and I sense a bit of a lag.
Sound analysis.
If you look at the design architecture of i5, it’s clear that Cayin didn’t intend it to be too far off the non-Android N5 version. The way I see it, the intent of i5 design was to give N5 streaming capability by converting it to Android-based DAP. In this conversion process, i5 lost second micro-SD card and balanced output, but gained touch screen interface, WiFi and BT, and of course that gorgeous volume wheel. I also believe there was a different opamp introduced in the design, which slightly affected the tonality and extension at the top end, but overall we are still dealing with a very balanced sound that oozes with natural, musical, neutral tonality, slightly titled toward the warmer side. If you are familiar with N5, don’t expect drastic changes, and I will go over them in my Comparison section where I will look at Cayin family of N5, N6, and i5.
I know everybody has a different reference points when trying to describe sound signature of a DAP. It’s not an easy task because headphones own sound signature plays a big role in this equation. I went through many different IEMs and full size cans, covering different sound signatures, and arrived to one common conclusion. The neutral, natural tonality of i5 pairs up great with most of them. The only pair up I wasn’t happy about was with sensitive IEMs (like Zeus) where I find hissing to be a bit distracting. I hope in their next N-series design, Cayin can find a better compromise in terms of background hiss level. With i-series, they got too much other mainstream consumer stuff on their plate, but audiophile focused N-series would benefit greatly if the hissing with sensitive IEMs is reduced.
Of course, using external portable amp can solve this problem, or you can just turn i5 into a digital transport and drive your external DAC/amp. The pair up with Micro iDSD was fantastic, very transparent clean sound which I enjoyed with all my IEMs and full size cans, and thanks to built-in IEMatch, I don’t have to worry about hissing.
Also, don’t forget that you have Bluetooth Wireless support which only depends on wireless encoding of the audio and the quality of your headphones decoding circuit. Though aptX is not supported, lately I have noticed that many higher end wireless headphones use their own DSP sound enhancement where sometimes it’s hard to even tell a difference between aptX and non-aptX. This difference is more audible with cheaper wireless headphones that use lower grade chipsets that limit bandwidth.
Comparison.
When I was reviewing N5, many people wanted to know how it compares to their flagship N6. Obviously, with introduction of i5, people are curious how it compares to its N5 sibling and if it’s considered to be an upgrade or side grade. I will cover below sound comparison of i5 to N5 and N6. As far as i5 vs N5 goes, in my opinion it’s a side-grade where you need to figure out if you want streaming and Bluetooth support and OK with less storage, or if you want more storage (dual microSD) and balanced HO port. In more details:
i5 vs N5 – both have a very similar sound signature and tonality, resolution and transparency, including layering of the sound and soundstage expansion. The only noticeable difference is that i5 sounds a bit smoother at the top end. We are not talking about warmer or less resolving sound but I have tested these with a few sibilant test tracks which sound more pronounced on N5 but have smoother upper peaks on i5. Also, I prefer touch screen interface controls over mechanical wheel in this case.
i5 vs N6 – this comparison is very similar to how I heard N5 vs N6, where N6 has a brighter tonality with a more revealing sound which gets closer to analytical retrieval of details. N6 sound also has more transparency and airiness, while i5 sound is smoother, a little warmer, and with more body in comparison. At the same time, I hear i5 to have a wider soundstage than N6. Both DAPs have a resolving sound, just a difference in tonality and transparency. Also, despite flagship status, N6 is starting to feel a bit outdated, and in need of a refresh.
Next comparison could be perceived as a bit “controversial”. With a recent introduction of FiiO’s X5 3rd gen, not sure if it's still a collaboration with Hiby, many people turned to a new shiny toy, forgetting about their lost “hero”. Both are great DAPs with their own strengths and weaknesses, and targeted at the same consumer audience who want a compact design with a decent audio quality and streaming capability. So, let’s take a closer look.
i5 vs X5iii – in comparison, i5 has a little wider soundstage, while the staging depth is the same in both. The bass in i5 is more layered with a better articulation, while X5iii bass sounds a little more one dimensional in comparison. Both have a very similar bass extension and impact. Upper mids in i5 are a little brighter and more revealing, including treble having more sparkle and airiness, while X5iii is a little smoother and more organic, including a little smoother treble. I think that’s one of the biggest differences between these two DAPs, where i5 has an edge in sound quality due to a better upper end extension and more airiness which expands the dynamics of the sound, while X5iii sounds a little flatter in comparison.
My testing was done comparing Single Ended 3.5mm outputs, volume matched, between these DAPs. When comparing i5 to X5iii BAL HO, I hear an improvement in sound where X5iii is a little more dynamic now, but still doesn't reach i5 level. Also, both have a very noticeable hissing with sensitive IEMs (like Zeus), though i5 is a little stronger and with a higher pitch sound.
When it comes to a design, i5 has a more premium solid look, but X5iii has a more practical and a more comfortable one handed operation since playback controls and volume wheel are on the same side and the volume wheel is a lot easier to turn. Also, despite having the same 32GB of internal storage, X5iii has two microSD slots.
In terms of GUI design and interface, X5iii offers a more smartphone-like experience which is smoother when dealing with Google Play store and apps, while in case of i5 the Android apps feel like a hidden add-on. That’s one of the biggest differences, where X5iii feels like Android OS with FiiO music app on top of it, while i5 feels more like an audio DAP with a limited Android access to allow apps on top of it. It's a very different experience that could attract different users. If you are into audio streaming and apps and need more storage, X5iii will suite your needs better. If you just want access to streaming apps and your focus is on better audio quality, i5 has a definitive edge here. Keep in mind, i5 has a single AK4490 DAC while X5iii has two AK4490 DACs, and it's a good example that more DACs doesn't mean a better sound quality.
Conclusion.
With headphones, they stay longer in demand, and some even become classics. Once you put headphones on your consideration list, you can revisit it 6-12 months later and still find it relevant. With DAPs, especially Android-based, the momentum is right before the releases and maybe 2-3 months afterwards, until something new is announced for release. There is too much progress in a field of DAC chips, storage options, Android releases, different flavors of hw controls, and updates in various standards (like Bluetooth). Plus, when you are dealing with app support, your hardware and OS version can become obsolete and not-supported in a short future. It’s a risk for a manufacturer when they step out of audiophile-centered design with a better longevity, and step into a more mainstream consumer design where you must keep up with the latest trends that change every 4-6 months.
Personally, I don’t use streaming as much, but do recognize it has a huge selling factor for many consumers. I do appreciate Cayin’s approach to bring audio player functionality to the front, and Android app support to the background which suites my needs, but maybe not others. It was their first attempt to test Android waters, and I hope it won’t be their last. As a matter of fact, I hope for the touch screen interface to appear in their N-series flagship release, because mechanical and button scroll controls feel rather outdated today. Regarding i5, I still think it’s relevant despite other competitive releases, and perhaps with future updates Cayin team can optimize it further to make operation smoother since it still has some lag. In terms of audio, it sounds as good as their N5 mid-fi DAP, and you have plenty of power and a great pair up synergy with a wide range of IEMs and full size headphones. Maybe, it’s not a new kid on the block, but Cayin i5 is still a relevant choice when you are looking for a great sounding DAP with a bold solid design and support for WiFi streaming and wireless Bluetooth, all under $500.