LarsHP
Headphoneus Supremus
Power is obviously not the reason to go for a speaker amp instead of a headphone amp. Why exactly a high end speaker amp often is better is not easy to tell. Basically there is no general physical / electrical property that you can theoretically say is the key to why HE-6 performs better with a speaker amp than a high quality headphone amp, because the impedance curve of planars is practically flat, which means there is no driver resonance for the amp to control. It's impedance is about 50 Ohms, which isn't particularly low either. The sensitivity is extremely low for a headphone, but very high for a speaker. However, in terms of power - in order to produce undistorted peaks in the music - the high powered headphone amps, that do about or more than 2W in 50 Ohm, actually have what it takes - again - theoretically.
The only useful explanation is that high end speaker amps for some reason are better amps than powerful high end headphone amps.
As a "funny" story, I would like to add something to underline that power is not what it's all about: I have had a high powered (5W class A) Norwegian DIY headphone amp for a year, but the built-in balanced amp card in my HiFiMan HM901S yields better and deeper bass and doesn't have the excess treble either. Go figure that!
There might be one thing that could explain why speaker amps are better, and that is the driving principle: it's push - pull. However, I'm not an engineer, so this is just guesswork.
The only useful explanation is that high end speaker amps for some reason are better amps than powerful high end headphone amps.
As a "funny" story, I would like to add something to underline that power is not what it's all about: I have had a high powered (5W class A) Norwegian DIY headphone amp for a year, but the built-in balanced amp card in my HiFiMan HM901S yields better and deeper bass and doesn't have the excess treble either. Go figure that!
There might be one thing that could explain why speaker amps are better, and that is the driving principle: it's push - pull. However, I'm not an engineer, so this is just guesswork.