I spent an hour listening to the Focal Elegia today with my Hugo, and comparing it with my IEMs.
I was expecting a lot, but was somewhat disappointed and found my Sony IER-M9 to be better in almost every way.
Background:
Music styles: Classic, Jazz, Acoustic, vocals, some Pop, Rock, and electronic
(I used to play the piano and am quite sensitive to correct reproduction of classical music)
Only started with headphone Hifi a few years ago with a Chord Mojo, first Audioquest NightHawk, then got into IEMs
My top IEM is the Sony IER-M9, runner up is the Moondrop Blessing 2
Got the Hugo 2 a week ago, love it, and am thinking about getting a pair of over ear headphones, mainly for my aging father to use with the Mojo, but also to use with the Hugo.
I’d like to keep the costs low, ideally below €500, not more than 700, but it can be used too.
Looked around and identified the Focal Elear, Hifiman Sundara, Sennheiser HD 6... and maybe a used Dan Clark Audio Aeon 2 closed as possible candidates.
Testing the Elear today, compared to the Sony IER-M9 I found:
- soundstage of M9 much deeper, much better positioning and separation. Elear sounded open, but soundstage still more in my head and no clear positioning.
- detail, resolution and clarity was better by a big margin with the M9
- the M9 is a warm IEM, but the Elear was warmer, with a more veiled and muffled midrange
- even dynamics felt better with the M9, with crisper leading edges and transients, the Elear had good punch though
Sooooo...
I will have a chance to listen to a Sundara, maybe I’ll also listen again to the Austrian Audio Hi-X55.
I have a chance to get a used DCA AEON 2 Closed, but can’t test it beforehand.
What would be your recommendations for a lower price headphone which does well with classical and acoustic music, has good detail, soundstage and positioning?
Am I expecting to much?
For those who use the Hugo with both full size headphones as well as IEMs, what are your experiences?
I was honestly shocked that the M9 had a much better soundstage than the Elear....