[Nada190]

I compress them and before I get anywhere near my ears, it's fully expanded again. I tried compressing directly next to my ear and then quickly putting them in and this barely works too, expands way too fast.
 
I'm using Comply tips. It wasn't like this when I first got them. 
 
Does it have something to do with the way I store them? I just put my earbuds into my drawer without any case. Really annoying.
 
Anyone know what I can do? I've only had these for 1 month with rare usage (3-5 times)

 

[ProtegeManiac]

I think that's more likely because you're not using them enough, and so they're too predisposed to their original shape.

 

[NA Blur]

If you clean them with water they lose their somewhat stiff elasticity.  Perhaps you cleaned them once?

 

[Nada190]

Never cleaned them. I guess it makes since that not using them enough causes them to just want to stay in shape.