Heresy, Lunacy, or BRILLIANCE - I go with
https://www.clemson.edu/bluecheese/ over Maytag. I think it's made from pasteurized milk, so it violates some "rule" or another, but it's fabulous.
The Cady cheese factory has some wonderful offerings.
http://www.cadycheese.com/
- As a sub for bricks of Kerrygold Dubliner cheddar from Costco (which admittedly I like very much) - I use their 2 yr. old aged cheddar
- Their 17 yr old cheddar is one of my favorite treats. Occasionally, you can get 19. They generally have 2 to 9 regularly - I'm not sure what they keep for mail order.
- If you want some "squeaky cheese" for your curds - look no further. White, Yellow, or a mixed bag...
- Their medium Colby is one my favorites for grilled-cheese
- Their Parmesan is not a direct substitute for any of the properly-aged cheeses from Italy, but it's hard to beat for the cost. It doesn't have a terribly deep flavor, but it is a phenomenal substitute the pre-grated "cheese" from a plastic green container (at roughly the same price per unit weight or a tad more).
And - since we can combine beer too... It's right up the street from Dave's Brew Farm -
http://davesbrewfarm.blogspot.com/