I was loaned an XI Formula S, Powerman and Utopia from the Cable Company which I received on Thursday.
Wow - Dave > Formula S > Abyss TC is an amazing combo. It sounds much more transparent than my v281.
I have listened for the past three nights and don't have deep detailed notes or impressions, but the head stage expands, the mids are more fluid, the bass is more powerful - and the treble is slightly sweeter. Effectively the biggest change is that I can listen to a much wider range of music and have it sound fantastic - and it's not a question of gain. The Dave does have enough power to drive the abyss loudly enough for the music I listen to. What I'm finding is with Flim Scores, Electronic Orchestral, Classical, - even those that don't have an incredibly high dynamic range - they just sound better - and it's not a small change. As this is a lot of what I listen to, it's very important! Something is going on in the mids that I can't put my finger on. Previously, this type of music didn't sound quite right to me on the Dave direct. Now they sound the best I've ever heard them. I think this makes the Abyss TC supplant the Stax 009 as my favorite headphone. Will have to wait until I overcome new toy syndrome to be sure!
For some rock, especially with distorted guitars, I still prefer the Dave direct a little. For some reason, the slight reduction in transparency seems to be more noticeable there. It seems counter intuitive to me as I would think this would be more apparent on other types of music. I'll have to listen to a bit more to try and get a handle on where the Dave direct shines, but in the vast majority of cases the Formula S provides a significant improvement. I am wowed.
Comparing to the Formula S to the v281 it is a dramatic improvement IMHO. My major problem is that the Abyss sounds too dark on the v281. I felt like it diminished some of the treble magic the Abyss TC has. It's there on the Dave direct.
I got the Utopia again, even though I've demoed them before, because I didn't have a Dave then. Running through a Yggy or Auralic Vega and my v281 rolled off the sound a bit, previously as well. Dave direct they sound much, much better. I am quite enjoying them. That said - because I don't have endless pockets - I'll purchase the Forumla S and Powerman for now - as it's quite a chunk of change. As I have the Abyss TC, I feel like I don't really have a need for them - outside of the desire to have a flagship headphone that I run directly through the Dave.
This may be an over simplification - but the overall sound signature / tonal balance of the Utopia direct through the Dave, and the Abyss TC with Formula S sound quite similar. The Abyss however has this massive soundstage and (imaging seems better as a result, because the Utopia feels somewhat congested in comparison). The Bass on the Abyss, especially with the Formula S, is tight, deep, and incredibly tactile - better than I've ever heard on any headphone.
Interestingly, so far I still prefer my LCD 4 on the Violectric V281. While I think the Abyss (and 009 for that matter) are superior, the LCD 4, IMO, has the best mids I've ever heard on a headphone. This is more pronounced on the V281, and the upper treble is ever so slightly rolled off. Because of the lift in the upper treble with the LCD 4, I get fatigued listening to it Dave direct, or via the Formula S - so it almost needs it. In addition, it has more bass quantity on the V281 - which may just be due to the slightly decreased treble and its effect on tonal balance. The LCD4 and V281 just have this synergy I've always liked, which I can't seem to replicate with other amps. While I was hoping to sell the v281 if I bought the Formula S, I think I may keep both. The LCD 4/v281 just does something that none of my other headphones do - and provides another flavor.
This is my headphone listening station I've set up in my loft. A respite from the wife and kids. The best deal there is probably the $600 Raymour and Flanigan motorized recliner. It reclines completely flat, and has separate adjustments for your head, so you can recline pretty far, while still keeping your head upright with the Abyss, which is incredibly comfortable! May get another rack to replace the bar/headphone stand - but it works for now:
Anyway, for now back to listening! I have some great headphones - and as a result I haven't been wowed in a long time. I'm wowed again.