Sony is buying back my XM4's that developed the battery issue. This made me consider getting XM5's more than I would have after experiencing that drastic nosedive in performance. But instead I got the AirPods Pro 2. I was expecting more of a compromise, sacrificing sound for convenience, and so far that's not the case.
- Been listening back and forth with my XM4's and I think I actually prefer the APP2 sound better. It's more...alive? More wide-ranging? (I'm not sure of the correct terminology.) The bass is heavier, maybe too much at times, and I'll be looking into an EQ app. But it's much better than I was expecting.
- It turns out I like to use transparency mode just as much as noise cancelling, and the one on the AirPods seems more natural to me. Time will tell if ANC is comparable -- I plan to get some foam tips to recreate the passive noise cancelling of the XM4's. So far the stock tips are not terrible but I haven't been on a plane, on a busy street, etc.
- Since I got the XM4's in 2021, I use buds for calls and meetings much more than I thought I would, and the Apple ecosystem factor is real.
- I think the oval shape on the APP2 fits my ears better. I got used to a whole long process for getting the XM4's seated and sealed in my ears, and it seems like I can basically slap the AirPods in and call it good.
But I'm still interested in having an awesome-sound-inside-a-bubble experience, so I will keep an eye on this thread to see how the XM5's play out. Couple things are currently dealbreakers for me, and I'll be curious to see if firmware changes remove them:
- The volume control. That's far too many taps! Would drive me nuts inside a day.
- Needing to create a Sony account and log in to get the best ANC performance. No thanks.
I appreciate everyone's opinions and advice here! Off to see if the AirPods Pro 2 threads are as informative.